| As we face the challenges of our
Earth Century, Adrian Glamorgan urges a spirit of conscious
enquiry
Ever
bought something you desired instead of just needed?
The art and science that capitalises on our instinctual
and unconscious desires as unsustainable mass consumers
emerged with an American, Edward Louis Bernays (1891-1995),
Sigmund Freud's nephew no less. Bernays took the psychoanalytic
theories of his famous Viennese uncle and applied them
to politics and advertising, simultaneously inventing
the shadowy occupation of public relations.
If you've ever wondered why we keep on buying things
we don't really need, or expect satisfaction from each
purchase yet immediately hanker for the next thing,
look to Bernays for some ready answers.
Eddie Bernays' "engineering of consent,"
involved all kinds of ventures that delved deep into
our unconscious. In 1928, the American Tobacco Company
wanted to expand the profitable cigarette market to
include women, but there was a cultural barrier against
women smoking in public. So they turned to Bernays.
He organised a group of 10 young women to march in the
New York parade and, at the right moment in front of
photographers he hired, the women produced and lit their
Lucky Strike cigarettes according to a careful script,
claiming they were lighting "torches of freedom".
Breaking the tobacco taboo was a symbolic Freudian way
of challenging male power. It also started selling a
lot of cigarettes to women.
Bernays' particular talent in shaping consumption was
to bring in third party "independent" research,
to help persuade consumers they needed something. Through
his tireless efforts, Americans came to believe that
fluoridation would be wonderful for dental health, just
when the aluminium companies wanted somewhere to put
their waste product; that heavy breakfasts were healthy,
just when bacon producers needed more pork to be sold;
that cars needed better ventilation just at the time
General Motors produced an innovation in its windows.
Bernays would commission a survey that would find white
unperfumed soap was preferred, just when only one such
product existed - his client's. These days, the wine
industry produces reports about how good red wine is
(for men, in a narrow age bracket), the nuclear industry
reports on how safe Chernobyl fallout was, and medical
authorities and pharmaceutical companies fund studies
critical of alternative medicine. The toxic sludge industry
is quite possibly commissioning an independent report
on the advantages of chemical waste on our skin pores,
even as we speak. Fair go. Whenever you read a survey
popping out of nowhere in the newspapers, ask who commissioned
it?
Bernays openly declared what he was doing: "it
is now possible to control and regiment the masses according
to our will without their knowing it," he maintained.
"Those who manipulate this unseen mechanism of
society constitute an invisible government which is
the true ruling power of our country.... In almost every
act of our daily lives, whether in the sphere of politics
or business, in our social conduct or our ethical thinking,
we are dominated by the relatively small number of persons
... who understand the mental processes and social patterns
of the masses. It is they who pull the wires which control
the public mind."
This manipulation of democracy and free market by the
"intelligent few" to protect us all from chaos,
and sell lots of products, backfired tragically. In
1933, Bernays discovered his Crystallizing Public Opinion-
was being used by Goebbels to orchestrate the Nazi persecution
of the Jews. But he was not beyond using these same
propaganda methods closer to home. On behalf of the
United Fruit Company, Bernays advised how best to undermine
Guatemala's democratically elected President Guzman.
The CIA did the rest.
People had to be persuaded to throw away possessions
to create rubbish. During the Great Depression, Bernays
set up the Committee for the Study and Promotion of
the Sanitary Dispensing of Food and Drink, which found
disposable cups, produced by his client, Dixie Cups,
were more "sanitary". For Mack trucks, Bernays
created fronts such as the Better Living through Increased
Highway Transportation. Waste and more greenhouse gases,
unsustainability, all just an independent survey away.
Now we are living in a century when a response to the
ecological crisis is urgent. In February, the Stratigraphy
Commission of the Geological Society of London, the
oldest association of Earth scientists, determined that
the old Holocene Epoch, the geological time cradling
our species into existence, has come to an abrupt halt,
with the Earth entering "a stratigraphic interval
without close parallel in the last several million years".
As well as greenhouse gases building up, human monoculture
and cities have transformed the natural sediments, acidified
the oceans, and overseen species extinction, "producing
a distinctive contemporary biostratigraphic signal".
It means the work of the last 200 years is being written
into the rocks. Through our actions, Earth has entered
into the Anthropocene Epoch, an entirely new geological
age, in our lifetime. That is how profound the change
effected by humans is.
Garnaut's draft report confirms this - the most ambitious
emission reduction plans only give us a 50-50 chance
to save the Great Barrier Reef. Sobering indeed. I'm
not sure that those in corporate and governmental power
actually properly grasp the enormity of what's happening
across our country. Expect "independent" studies
commissioned by the coal industry. Expect to hear arguments
that we "can't afford" to do something about
climate change. Prepare for people who are brought forward
who do not "believe" in greenhouse gases -
as if it was something you decided to barrack for or
not. It is not a time for the "intelligent few"
to decide we can wait a little longer till the world
joins in action. Fear, doubt and xenophobia may be persuasive
instincts, but they are not a measure to help save an
ecosystem.
No point blaming Bernays or greenwashing industry, soft-pedalling
the environmental crisis; no point in decrying the advertising
agencies re-employed to launch us into faraway wars;
no point decrying the modern day Goebbels or United
Fruit Companies. Expect smoke and mirrors. Blow away
the smokescreen and see clearly - it is entirely up
to us. We wish for truth, understanding and action.
We will need, not self defeating cynicism, but conscious
enquiry. We need to question, but not destroy our trust
in each other through our questions. Such a delicate
balance!
The Earth Century calls for a revived ecological sensibility,
one on a global scale as well as an interior measure,
that connects with others and the other inside the self.
It will acknowledge our vulnerability to fear, doubt
and hate. It will dare to respond with courage, openness
and compassion. It will acknowledge the persuasiveness
of our strange desires, without giving ultimate power
to them; attempt to rise from the half-dream called
consumerism to face the glare of the newest, ecological
century, with a new kind of humility and wonder. A new
geological age has begun: perhaps, too, a new human
consciousness is emerging with it.
|